Two Canadian ETFs I Watch as Market and Economic Indicators
Last Updated:

There are plenty of indicators that institutional and retail investors monitor to get a sense of where markets might be headed. Beyond major equity benchmarks such as the S&P/TSX Composite Index and S&P/TSX 60, there's the Bank of Canada's policy interest rate, Government of Canada bond yields and an assortment of economic indicators covering everything from inflation to employment.
As someone who spends a considerable amount of time analyzing ETFs, I've had the opportunity to explore some less conventional corners of the Canadian market. Along the way, I've identified a handful of ETFs, some well-known and others relatively obscure, that I personally find useful to keep an eye on.
Indexes are mathematical constructs that track the performance of a defined basket of securities. ETFs, meanwhile, are live investment vehicles through which investors actively express their views. Beyond their price performance, I can examine fund inflows and outflows for clues about sentiment, while their specialized exposures can help me gauge how particular investment themes are playing out.
Of course, ETF flows aren't a perfect sentiment indicator, and performance alone doesn't necessarily validate a theory. But when interpreted alongside other market data, I find that certain funds provide a useful sanity check on my own assumptions, even when I have no intention of investing in them.
Today, I'll highlight two Canadian-listed ETFs that I regularly monitor for precisely that purpose. I'll explain how each works, which metrics I pay attention to and what I think those signals can tell us.
High Interest Savings Account Fund (HISA)
One thing I appreciate about the Canadian ETF landscape is the variety of choices available for cash management. Beyond conventional money market funds, investors can access Treasury bill ETFs and, among the longest-standing options, high-interest savings account ETFs (HISA ETFs). Chief among them is the aptly named High Interest Savings Account Fund (HISA), offered by Evolve ETFs.
HISA is about as straightforward as an ETF gets. After deducting its 0.16% management expense ratio (MER), the fund currently pays monthly distributions equivalent to a 2.37% net annualized yield as of November 13. That yield is variable and generally moves in the same direction as the Bank of Canada's policy interest rate, although changes aren't necessarily immediate or proportional.
That's one reason I like monitoring HISA. Rather than relying exclusively on whatever the Bank of Canada announces at its latest meeting, I can observe the actual yield available to investors at any given time through a relatively low-risk, liquid product. It's a useful approximation of what investors can earn on cash after fees, although HISA isn't technically risk-free or covered by deposit insurance.
But there's another reason I watch it: to see just how badly Canada's big banks are shortchanging the average saver. Bear with me here.
HISA's underlying strategy is simple. The ETF deposits money into institutional high-interest savings accounts at major Canadian banks. Because Evolve is placing substantial institutional deposits, it can negotiate rates that ordinary retail depositors can't access.
And that's where things get interesting. These same banks offer savings accounts directly to consumers, sometimes advertising attractive promotional rates. But once those promotions expire, the regular interest rates can be considerably lower than what institutional depositors receive.
HISA effectively bridges that gap. Evolve takes 16 basis points annually in expenses, which I consider reasonable for providing access to institutional deposit rates through an exchange-traded product. Investors receive the remaining interest income, subject to fluctuations in those underlying rates.
So, whenever I'm comparing savings accounts, I like looking at HISA's net yield alongside the regular rates offered by Canada's Big Five banks. The difference provides a quick indication of how much interest income a retail saver might be leaving on the table simply by keeping cash in a bank account.
Of course, the comparison isn't entirely apples to apples. A savings account may offer Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation protection on eligible deposits, whereas HISA ETF units aren't CDIC-insured. ETF investors also face bid-ask spreads and brokerage commissions. Nevertheless, if your bank is offering a fraction of HISA's yield on an ordinary savings account, I'd consider that a good reason to shop around.
iShares Canadian Growth Index ETF (XCG)
There's a long-standing joke that Canada's stock market is basically a handful of banks and energy companies in a trench coat. And there's a modicum of truth to that. The S&P/TSX 60 Index currently has approximately 41% of its weight in financials and another 17% in energy.
Banking, pipelines and natural resources are among Canada's traditional economic strengths. But this concentration also means that when investors use the major Canadian equity indexes as a barometer for the broader economy, their conclusions can be disproportionately influenced by just two sectors.
One solution is to break the market down into individual sector ETFs. Another, which I personally find more convenient, is to put the iShares Canadian Growth Index ETF (XCG) on your watchlist. XCG tracks the Dow Jones Canada Select Growth Index, which selects 34 Canadian companies exhibiting above-average expected earnings growth.
The resulting sector composition looks considerably different from the S&P/TSX 60. Financials account for just 1.34% of XCG, while energy represents only 3.33%. Materials, particularly mining companies, still carry considerable influence at approximately 37%, reflecting Canada's substantial resource sector. But other sectors receive much greater representation. Industrials account for roughly 25% of the portfolio, followed by information technology at 21% and consumer discretionary at 8%.
I find this composition useful because it offers a different perspective on Canada's economy. Industrials provide exposure to capital spending, transportation and business investment. Information technology reflects demand for software, digital infrastructure and other technology services, while consumer discretionary companies are more directly exposed to household spending and consumer confidence.
These aren't perfect proxies for economic activity, particularly given that many Canadian-listed companies generate substantial revenue internationally. Nevertheless, they offer a useful counterweight to the banks and energy producers that dominate the headline indexes.
Growth stocks also tend to be more sensitive to changes in earnings expectations, financing conditions and investor risk appetite. When the economic outlook improves, investors may become more willing to pay for anticipated future growth. Conversely, rising discount rates can put pressure on valuations. That's why I like monitoring XCG's performance relative to the broader Canadian market.
If the S&P/TSX 60 is performing well primarily because banks, pipelines or energy producers are rallying, while XCG is lagging, I might question how broadly that strength extends across the economy. Sustained outperformance from XCG could suggest improving sentiment toward growth-oriented businesses, capital investment and consumer-facing industries.
Would I actually invest in XCG? Probably not. For one thing, the ETF charges a 0.55% management expense ratio (MER). That might have been reasonable when it launched in November 2006, but it's difficult to justify for a passive equity ETF today, particularly when broad Canadian market exposure is available for a fraction of the cost.
The other issue is income, or the relative lack of it. Canadian investors have historically demonstrated a strong appetite for dividend-paying equities, and XCG's trailing 12-month distribution yield of just 0.52% isn't likely to impress that crowd.
But neither drawback matters much for my purposes. I'm interested in what XCG can tell me about the performance of Canadian growth companies relative to the country's traditional financial and resource sectors. For that, I think it earns a place on my watchlist, even if it doesn't earn a place in my portfolio.
